1.中国科学院西安光学精密机械研究所空间光学技术研究室,西安 710100
2.中国科学院大学光电学院,北京 101400
杨鼎(2002—),男,硕士,主要研究方向为光学系统设计。Email: yangding24@mails.ucas.ac.cn
李旭阳(1981—),男,研究员,博士,主要研究方向为高分辨率相机设计、成像质量评价等。Email: lixuyang2004@126.com
收稿:2026-01-27,
修回:2026-04-06,
录用:2026-04-17,
移动端阅览
杨鼎,庞睿国,卢作锋,等. 中红外折衍混合系统超低冷反射设计和分析[J].光子学报,2026,55(7):0722001
Yang Ding, Pang Ruiguo, Lu Zuofeng, et al. Optimization and Analysis of an Ultra-Low Narcissus in Mid-Infrared Refraction-Diffraction Hybrid Systems[J]. Acta Photonica Sinica, 2026, 55(7):0722001
杨鼎,庞睿国,卢作锋,等. 中红外折衍混合系统超低冷反射设计和分析[J].光子学报,2026,55(7):0722001 DOI: 10.3788/gzxb20265507.0722001. CSTR: 32255.14.gzxb20265507.0722001.
Yang Ding, Pang Ruiguo, Lu Zuofeng, et al. Optimization and Analysis of an Ultra-Low Narcissus in Mid-Infrared Refraction-Diffraction Hybrid Systems[J]. Acta Photonica Sinica, 2026, 55(7):0722001 DOI: 10.3788/gzxb20265507.0722001. CSTR: 32255.14.gzxb20265507.0722001.
随着红外探测器的不断发展,包括像素尺寸的减小和灵敏度的提高,光学系统对信噪比和分辨率的要求也随之增加,本文讨论了红外波段的折衍混合系统的超低冷反射分析和优化问题,并给出了设计得到的具有超低冷反射的仿真结果。本文采用了定性和定量的分析方法,对传统的
YNI
和
I/IBAR
评估指标在对具有超低冷反射结果分析的局限性,指出了NITD(等效温差)在相关系统中的可行性。研究结果表明,通过综合指标分析系统各部分对像面的冷反射贡献并针对性优化,从衍射面到达像面的冷光线在像面的辐照度降低约40.5%,NITD最大值降至0.049 K,表明在针对性优化后能够设计出超低冷反射的系统,能够提高图像质量和温度测量的准确性。
This paper aims to realize an ultra-low Narcissus design for a cooled MWIR refraction-diffraction hybrid optical system containing a Diffractive Optical Element (DOE), while maintaining high imaging performance under a large relative aperture. The study is focused on three tasks: examining the applicability of conventional Narcissus evaluation criteria in a hybrid optical system, establishing a quantitative analysis route based on actual ray tracing, and obtaining an optical design with significantly suppressed Narcissus irradiance at the focal plane. The objective is to reduce residual Narcissus noise beyond the level achievable by routine low-Narcissus design, so that both image uniformity and temperature-measurement accuracy can be improved in a high-resolution cooled infrared imaging system.A combined qualitative and quantitative procedure was adopted. First, the conventional
YNI
and
I/IBAR
criteria, together with the diffractive correction of
YNI
for the DOE surface, were used to obtain an initial low-Narcissus solution and to evaluate the Narcissus tendency of individual optical surfaces. Second, in view of the limitations of these surface-based criteria in a comp
lex hybrid system, a quantitative evaluation framework based on NITD (Narcissus Induced Equivalent Temperature Difference) and reverse ray tracing was established to characterize the Narcissus effect at the focal plane. In this framework, the propagation paths of Narcissus rays were traced surface by surface, and the contribution of each optical surface to the focal-plane Narcissus irradiance was quantified. For the DOE, the analysis considered not only the design diffraction order, but also non-high-diffraction-efficiency wavelengths in the design order and the contribution of non-design diffraction orders. For the refractive part, the dominant Narcissus sources were identified through NITD contribution analysis and ray-path tracing. Based on these results, targeted optimization was carried out by adjusting the DOE structural parameters, modifying the optical power distribution of the rear group, and introducing additional aspheric degrees of freedom where necessary. The final design was implemented in ZEMAX for a 3–5 μm waveband, with a 165 mm focal length, F/1.65, 6° full field of view, 1024×1024 detector format, and 12 μm pixel size.The results show that YNI and I/IBAR can indicate the Narcissus tendency of individual surfaces, but they cannot accurately represent the actual Narcissus level of a complex refraction-diffraction hybrid optical system. Even when the calculated
YNI
or
I/IBAR
values of some surfaces appear favorable, the corresponding surfaces may still produce substantial contributions to the total NITD after full-path ray tracing is considered. For the DOE, the analysis demonstrates that Narcissus is not determined only by the nominal design-order rays; rays at non-high-efficiency wavelengths in the design order and rays generated by non-design diffraction orders also contribute to the focal-plane Narcissus irradiance. In the initial design, the maximum detector NITD reached approximately 0.2309 K, and the dominant contribution originated from the rear group, wit
h surface S7 acting as the principal Narcissus source. After targeted optimization, the irradiance of DOE-related Narcissus rays arriving at the focal plane decreased from about 270.4 to 160.9, corresponding to a reduction of approximately 40.5%. At the same time, the maximum total NITD was reduced to 0.0490 K. The dominant Narcissus contribution shifted from the original surface to S10, while the contributions of most other surfaces became lower and more balanced. In the optimized system, the Narcissus associated with S7, S8, and S9 was effectively suppressed, and the rear group was reconfigured by using aspheric surfaces at S7, S8, and S13, together with increased curvature of S9 and S10, so that reflected Narcissus rays were less likely to be recollected onto the focal plane. Meanwhile, the system maintained good imaging performance over the operating temperature range.For a cooled MWIR refraction-diffraction hybrid optical system, ultra-low Narcissus design cannot depend solely on conventional surface-based criteria such as
YNI
and
I/IBA
R. A more effective design route is to combine preliminary criterion-based screening with NITD-oriented actual ray tracing, then perform path-oriented optimization aimed at both suppressing Narcissus generation and weakening the recollection of Narcissus rays by the rear group. When the original structural degrees of freedom are insufficient, additional optical-surface freedom, especially the introduction of aspheric surfaces, is necessary to balance imaging performance and Narcissus suppression. The final design verifies that an ultra-low Narcissus level can be achieved in a DOE-containing cooled MWIR imaging system, and indicates that the key issue in further improvement lies in controlling the localized distribution of residual Narcissus irradiance on the focal plane.
PENG Yuan , WEI Hongda , LIU Yang , et al . Design of Refractive-Diffractive Hybrid Medium Wave Infrared Thermal Suppression Optical System in a Wide Temperature Range [J]. Infrared and Laser Engineering , 2024 , 53 ( 10 ): 203 - 213 .
彭远 , 魏鸿达 , 刘洋 , 等 . 宽温度范围内折衍混合中波红外消热差光学系统设计 [J]. 红外与激光工程 , 2024 , 53 ( 10 ): 203 - 213 . DOI: 10.3788/IRLA20240240 http://dx.doi.org/10.3788/IRLA20240240
NIE Huailei , MAO Shan , ZHAO Jianlin . Athermalization Design of Cooled Refractive-Diffractive Hybrid Dual-Band Infrared Optical System [J]. Acta Optica Sinica , 2023 , 43 ( 08 ): 383 - 391 .
聂怀乐 , 毛珊 , 赵建林 . 制冷型折衍混合双波段红外光学系统无热化设计 [J]. 光学学报 , 2023 , 43 ( 08 ): 383 - 391 .
ZHOU Zhengping , CHEN Heng , JI Hui , et al . Design of Lightweight Long-Wave Infrared Athermalized Optical System with Hybrid Refractive-Diffractive [J]. Laser & Optoelectronics Progress , 2022 , 59 ( 10 ): 392 - 397 .
周正平 , 陈恒 , 纪辉 , 等 . 折衍混合轻量化长波红外消热差光学系统设计 [J]. 激光与光电子学进展 , 2022 , 59 ( 10 ): 392 - 397 . DOI: 10.3788/lop202259.1022001 http://dx.doi.org/10.3788/lop202259.1022001
XU Huanyao , XU Liang , SHEN Xianchun , et al . Analysis of Influence of Long Back Focal Length on Athermal Design Based on Infrared Multispectral Camera [J]. Acta Physica Sinica , 2021 , 70 ( 18 ): 135 - 143 .
徐睆垚 , 徐亮 , 沈先春 , 等 . 基于红外多光谱相机分析长后焦距对无热化设计的影响 [J]. 物理学报 , 2021 , 70 ( 18 ): 135 - 143 .
LI Jie , LUO Xiao , WU Hanping , et al . Design of Airborne Infrared Optical System Based on Refraction/Diffraction Hybrid [J]. Laser & Infrared , 2020 , 50 ( 02 ): 215 - 223 .
李杰 , 罗箫 , 吴晗平 . 基于折/衍混合的机载红外光学系统设计 [J]. 激光与红外 , 2020 , 50 ( 02 ): 215 - 223 .
TAO Zhi , WANG Min , XIAO Weijun , et al . Design for Cooled Dual-band Infrared Refractive-Diffractive Hybrid Optical System of Athermalization and Wide FOV [J], Acta Photonica Sinica , 2017 , 46 ( 11 ): 195 - 203 .
陶郅 , 王敏 , 肖维军 , 等 . 折/衍混合大视场消热差红外双波段光学系统设计 [J]. 光子学报 , 2017 , 46 ( 11 ): 195 - 203 . DOI: 10.3788/gzxb20174611.1122004 http://dx.doi.org/10.3788/gzxb20174611.1122004
JAMES W , HOWARD , ABELIRVING R , et al . Narcissus: Reflections on Retroreflections in Thermal Imaging Systems [J]. Applied. Optics , 1982 , 21 ( 18 ), 3393 - 3397 .
LIU Tao . Tth Research of Narcissus for Diffractive Optical Elements [D]. Changchun University of Science and Technology , 2013 .
刘涛 . 衍射光学元件的冷反射特性研究 [D]. 长春理工大学 , 2013 .
LIU Tao , CUI Qingfeng , YANG Liangliang , et al . Evaluation and Control of Narcissus for Diffractive Surfaces in IR System [J], Chin Sci Bul , 2012 , 57 : 36 – 41 .
刘涛 , 崔庆丰 , 杨亮亮 , 等 . 红外光学系统中衍射面冷反射的分析与评价 [J]. 科学通报 , 2012 , 57 ( 01 ): 36 - 41 .
DONG Yiyou, Characterization of Narcissus in Refractive Diffraction-Cooled Infrared Optical Systems [D]. Changchun University of Science and Technology , 2024 .
董一优 . 折衍射致冷红外光学系统的冷反射特性研究 [D]. 长春理工大学 , 2024 .
SWEATT W C . Mathematical Equivalence Between a Holographic Optical Element and an Ultra-high index lens [J]. Journal of the Optical Society of America , 1979 , 69 ( 3 ): 486 - 487 .
MAO Shan . Design and Application of Imaging Diffractive Optical Elements [M]. Beijing : Science Press , 2024 : 37 - 39 .
毛珊 . 成像衍射光学元件设计及应用 [M]. 北京 : 科学出版社 , 2024 : 37 - 39 .
LI Hang . Research on Key Techniques for Medium Wave Infrared Target Detection Device [D]. Changchun Institute of Optics, Fine Mechanics and Physics , Chinese Academy of Sciences, 2017 .
李航 . 中波红外目标探测装置关键技术研究 [D]. 中国科学院长春光学精密机械与物理研究所 , 2017 .
XIE Hongbo , MENG Qingbin , YANG Lei , et al . Athermalization and Suppression of Narcissus for Medium-Wave Infrared Optical System [J]. Journal of Applied Optics , 2017 , 038 ( 003 ): 352 - 357 .
谢洪波 , 孟庆斌 , 杨磊 , 等 . 中波红外光学系统无热化设计和冷反射抑制 [J]. 应用光学 , 2017 , 038 ( 003 ): 352 - 357 .
WANG Hu , CHEN Qinfang , MA Zhanpeng , et al . Development and Prospect of Stray Light Suppression and Evaluation Technology (Invited) [J]. Acta Photonica Sinica , 2022 , 51 ( 7 ): 0751406 .
王虎 , 陈钦芳 , 马占鹏 , 等 . 杂散光抑制与评估技术发展与展望(特邀) [J]. 光子学报 , 2022 , 51 ( 07 ): 125 - 180 .
XING Zhenchong . Research on Miniature Telefocal Multiband Common Aperture Optical System [D]. Changchun Institute of Optics, Fine Mechanics and Physics ,Chinese Academy of Sciences, 2017 .
邢振冲 . 灵巧型长焦多波段共口径光学系统的研究 [D]. 中国科学院长春光学精密机械与物理研究所 , 2017 .
LIU Junpeng . Design and Analysis of Membrane Diffractive Image System, 2018 .
刘骏鹏 . 薄膜衍射成像系统设计与分析 [D]. 哈尔滨工业大学 , 2018 .
ZHOU Yan . Study on Design of Infrared Diffractive Imaging Optical System with Large Aperture [D]. The Institute of Optics and Electronics , The Chinese Academy of Sciences, 2021 .
周岩 . 大口径红外衍射成像光学系统设计研究 [D]. 中国科学院光电技术研究所 , 2021 .
0
浏览量
4
下载量
0
CSCD
关联资源
相关文章
相关作者
相关机构
京公网安备11010602201714号